Just like with pens and other writing and drawing tools, the ideal mechanical pencil for you is the one that you find most suitable for your needs. This goes beyond just performance, also considering factors such as comfort, style, and specific features like a retractable tip.
Here are a variety of options that range from affordable, lightweight mechanical pencils to robust, metal instruments that are engineering marvels. These options are more advanced and sophisticated compared to the common, uninspiring models that may have put you off mechanical pencils in the past.
Our pick
This metal pencil is a pleasure to use thanks to its smooth grip section and satisfying, solid knock.
The Blick Premier Mechanical Pencil is great value for less than $10 and is more reliable than other mechanical pencils. It features a unique double-click mechanism that instantly extends or retracts the lead sleeve, preventing accidental lead breakage. Additionally, it has a premium all-metal body, a cushioning mechanism to prevent lead breakage, a lead indicator, and anti-slip knurling for a smooth yet grippy feel. These features are not typically found at this price point, making the Blick Premier a solid choice for a mechanical pencil.
If you prefer heavier drafting pencils with rougher grips, the smooth grip of the Blick Premier may not be suitable for you. In that case, the rOtring 600 Mechanical Pencil 1, with its more textured grip, would be a better alternative. Although the Blick Premier is Japanese-made and available only at specific art stores, its features and performance make it worth the investment.
Widths available: 0.5 mm, 0.7 mm
Also great
Its rotating lead keeps the tip sharp as you write, making for the cleanest and most consistent writing—especially when you make short, non-cursive strokes.
The Uni Kuru Toga Pipe Slide is a lightweight, always-sharp option that looks and feels nicer than most similarly priced or cheaper plastic mechanical pencils. It has a retractable tip to prevent accidental piercing and rotates the lead to maintain a fine point. The comfortable, grooved grip and thicker barrel make it preferred by many testers over thinner-bodied, inexpensive pencils.
Widths available: 0.5 mm for the Pipe Slide; 0.3 mm, 0.5 mm, and 0.7 mm for the Kuru Toga Standard pencil
Upgrade pick
This metal drafting-style pencil doesn’t do anything fancy, but it feels and performs like an heirloom writing instrument.
If you appreciate the feel of solid, heavy metal over plastic and prioritize performance for drawing and diagrams, the traditional rOtring 600 Mechanical Pencil is a great choice. While it lacks retractability, it offers excellent lead stability for precise, reliable strokes. Testers preferred it over similarly priced alternatives due to its weight and performance.
Widths available: 0.5 mm, 0.7 mm
Also great
This capped mechanical pencil has the widest barrel of the models we tested and looks fancier than its modest price would suggest.
The Pentel Sharp Kerry is a stylish and unique option with a capped design that protects the lead and tip during travel. It has a wide barrel, making it comfortable to hold, and a premium look that belies its affordable price. Its smooth barrel might not suit everyone, but ultimately, design preferences are subjective.
Widths available: 0.5 mm, 0.7 mm
