We have reviewed close to 100 hose-end sprinklers starting from 2013, and after recent testing, we believe that the Melnor XT4200M is the best option for homeowners who want to maintain a typical rectangular lawn efficiently with a good quality-price ratio.
The XT4200M, with its sturdy metal base and user-friendly controls to adjust the length, width, and water flow, can withstand multiple seasons while keeping your lawn green without wasting water on the pavement.
Our Recommendation
The Melnor XT4200M, with good range, adjustability, and proven durability, stands out as a reliable and easy-to-use oscillating sprinkler compared to its competitors.
The Melnor XT4200M ensures even and consistent coverage of square or rectangular lawns up to approximately 4,000 square feet. Its controls are easy to adjust to fit any lawn layout, and its metal base provides more stability compared to plastic alternatives. Additionally, it does not require any additional hose adapters, making it one of the most straightforward models to operate. The XT4200M’s robust construction and positive user feedback indicate it can efficiently maintain your lawn for several seasons, backed by Melnor’s limited lifetime warranty for added protection.
Runner-up
This version of our top choice, with an all-plastic base, offers a slightly lower cost but sacrifices stability and durability. It can be a decent alternative if our top pick is not available.
The Melnor XT4200 is almost identical to our primary recommendation, except for its less stable plastic base. During testing, this model showed a slightly longer maximum spray distance, and although it exhibited more wind drift than the metal-based XT4200M, its similar controls allowed for easy adjustments to water flow and spray length. If the XT4200M is unavailable or if you prefer a slightly lower price point, the XT4200 is a viable option, although its all-plastic construction may not offer the same longevity as our top pick.
Great Alternative
This compact and efficient sprinkler provides more flexible coverage options than our top pick, but it may be more complex and costly than the average user needs.
The Gardena Oscillating Sprinkler ZoomMaxx, previously our top choice, offers highly customizable spray patterns among all sprinklers tested. However, it covers only about half the area of our primary pick, up to approximately 2,300 square feet. If you have an oddly shaped yard, investing in this model might be beneficial. It boasts user-friendly controls and consistent coverage with twin rows of nozzles. Nevertheless, it necessitates the use of a hose adapter (included) and comprises a significant number of plastic components.
